Age Before Beauty

Scott Bestul posed an interesting question for hunters in his November 6, Whitetail 365 blog post. Bestul sets up the scenario where you have two bucks working toward your stand. Given equal opportunity to harvest either deer which buck would you harvest? One buck is obviously the older buck sporting a huge body, a sway back, and sagging belly but has a less than impressive rack. The other buck is a much younger deer sporting a headgear that would easily be a Boone and Crockett buck. Check out the pictures that Bestul posted on his blog from a friends farm. Let us know which buck you would rather harvest and why. Would you choose the old cagey buck or the potential B&C buck?